gzip vs bzip2 at compressing random strings?

< /dev/urandom tr -dc A-Za-z0-9_ | head -c $((1024 * 1024)) | tee >(gzip -c > out.gz) >(bzip2 -c > out.bz) > /dev/null
Does that count as a win for bzip2?
Sample Output
$ \ls -l out*
-rw-r--r-- 1 chillu users 789711 2009-04-04 19:01 out.bz
-rw-r--r-- 1 chillu users 789947 2009-04-04 19:01 out.gz

-2
By: jnash
2009-04-04 13:23:01

What Others Think

I use bzip2 too all the time, even thought it's much slower, thinking it compresses way better. But what's that, like .01 % smaller? I think I'm reverting to gzip.
cbilson · 713 weeks ago
I use 'lzma --fast'. The speed is comparable to gzip and the compression is better than bzip2.
atoponce · 713 weeks ago
Love the one liner on its own merits, but disagree with the method. The data produced here isn't a fair representation. Such random data (though within a smaller gamut of 63 characters than the full 256) gives a result more akin to compressing an already compressed file.
peterc · 712 weeks and 6 days ago
I don't know the case for binary files but for text files bzip2 is significantly better. When I ran the following to compress human genome DNA sequence (3,010 MB total size) by gzip and bzip2: cat human_genome | tee >(gzip -c > out.gz) >(bzip2 -c > out.bz) > /dev/null The sizes of output files are; out.gz 892MB out.bz 782MB
alperyilmaz · 712 weeks and 6 days ago
@peterc: Of course. Thats why I titled it gzip vs bzip2 at compressing _random_ strings. This wasn't any technical comparison. I was just curious on what'd win on random strings :) @atoponce: Ah. Then you might want to add it to the races like so.. >(lzma --fast ...)
jnash · 712 weeks and 6 days ago
There are many types of random though. Random strings of normal distribution and format and really, really random strings. However, @alperyilmaz's experiment with DNA sequences is interesting. I guess DNA sequences aren't as random as I thought! Just for fun, I wondered what the performance would be like on the first sort of "random", say Markov chain generated text: ./markov | head -c 10000 | tee >(gzip -c > out.gz) >(bzip2 -c > out.bz) > /dev/null (markov generates several hundred Markov generated sentences using Macbeth as the source text) I tried it three times. In each case, the bzip2 file was 90%, 91%, and 90% of the gz file. So not as amazing as I'd have expected (and worse than the DNA sequence!!) Point of all of this? God knows but it was fun for a few minutes ;-)
peterc · 712 weeks and 5 days ago
And for those people voting this down, I think it's worth voting up not for what it specifically does, but because the latter part of the line provides a nice technique for comparing two compression techniques nonetheless :)
peterc · 712 weeks and 5 days ago
https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/   https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/ https://seofox.ir/add-site-in-google/
seofox · 54 weeks ago
Pug Puppies for Sale Near Me pugs puppies for sale teacup pugs for sale pug puppies for sale by owner pug puppies ohio PUG PUPPY FOR SALE NEAR ME PUG PUPPIES FOR SALE pug puppies for sale in kentucky Pug Puppies for Sale Under $500 Near Me pug puppies for sale in texas pug puppies for sale $200 pugs for sale near me under $500 pugs for sale under $400 near me pugs for sale near me puppies for sale near me under $500 pug puppies for sale under $1,000 near me pug for sale pug puppies for sale under $300 Brindle Pug Pitbull Pug Mix Pugs for sale cheap Cheap pug affordable pug puppies for sale near me black pugs for sale near me White Pugs for sale pug dog for sale free pug puppies pug puppies for sale in my area mn pug breeders pug puppies indiana pugs for sale michigan PUG PUPPY ADOPTION Pug puppies for sale Pug puppies for sale near me Pug puppies near me Pug Puppies for Sale Under $500 Near Me Cute Pug Puppies Black pug puppies Black pug puppies for sale pug puppies for adoption black pug puppies for sale near me chihuahua pug mix puppies how much is a pug puppy teacup pug puppies baby pug puppies pictures of pug puppies pug puppies for sale in Ohio pug puppies price pug mix puppies teacup pug puppies for sale best food for pug puppy newborn pug puppies pug puppies craigslist pug puppies for sale craigslist adorable pug puppies how much does a pug puppy cost Pitbull pug mix puppies pug pit mix puppy pug puppies for sale $200 pug puppies for sale in NJ Pug puppies for sale in Wisconsin pug puppy cost pug puppy food royal canin pug puppy royal canin pug puppy food fawn pug puppy pug puppies for sale florida pug puppies for sale in Indiana pug puppies for sale in KY pug puppies for sale in NC pug dog puppy AKC Registered Pug Puppies For sale cheap pug puppies for sale near me cheap pug puppies for sale in California cheap pug puppies for sale in nj Black Pug Puppies for sale pugs puppies for sale pug puppies indiana Amazing! This blog looks just like my old one! It's on a completely different subject but it has pretty much the same layout and design. Wonderful choice of colors!
rahimhh21 · 12 weeks and 5 days ago
Since 2008, Perfect House Pug Puppies has been the leading Pug puppy breeder in the US, providing premium Pug puppies for sale. Each puppy exhibits the professionalism and knowledge that have set Perfect House Pug puppies apart from other pug puppy breeders. The professionals at Perfect House Pug Puppies are dedicated about finding their puppies loving, beloved homes where they can enjoy long, healthy lives. A companion that has been produced for quality, health, and temperament that satisfies the breed standard is guaranteed by Perfect House Pug puppies, the pug breeder that has set the benchmark for exceptional customer satisfaction. If you are looking to buy a baby pug, Black and white pugs, Mini pug puppies for sale, Black and tan pug for sale, Teacup pug puppies for sale, Female pug puppies, pug puppies for sale, pug puppies for sale near me, pug puppies for sale under $500 near me. Pug Puppies for Sale Near Me pugs puppies for sale teacup pugs for sale pug puppies for sale by owner pug puppies ohio PUG PUPPY FOR SALE NEAR ME PUG PUPPIES FOR SALE pug puppies for sale in kentucky Pug Puppies for Sale Under $500 Near Me pug puppies for sale in texas pug puppies for sale $200 pugs for sale near me under $500 pugs for sale under $400 near me pugs for sale near me puppies for sale near me under $500 pug puppies for sale under $1,000 near me pug for sale pug puppies for sale under $300 Brindle Pug Pitbull Pug Mix Pugs for sale cheap Cheap pug affordable pug puppies for sale near me black pugs for sale near me White Pugs for sale pug dog for sale free pug puppies pug puppies for sale in my area mn pug breeders pug puppies indiana pugs for sale michigan PUG PUPPY ADOPTION Pug puppies for sale Pug puppies for sale near me Pug puppies near me Pug Puppies for Sale Under $500 Near Me Cute Pug Puppies Black pug puppies Black pug puppies for sale pug puppies for adoption black pug puppies for sale near me chihuahua pug mix puppies how much is a pug puppy teacup pug puppies baby pug puppies baby pug puppies for sale pictures of pug puppies pug puppies for sale in Ohio pug puppies price pug mix puppies teacup pug puppies for sale best food for pug puppy newborn pug puppies pug puppies craigslist pug puppies for sale craigslist adorable pug puppies how much does a pug puppy cost Pitbull pug mix puppies pug pit mix puppy pug puppies for sale $200 pug puppies for sale in NJ Pug puppies for sale in Wisconsin pug puppy cost pug puppy food royal canin pug puppy royal canin pug puppy food fawn pug puppy pug puppies for sale florida pug puppies for sale in Indiana pug puppies for sale in KY pug puppies for sale in NC pug dog puppy AKC Registered Pug Puppies For sale cheap pug puppies for sale near me cheap pug puppies for sale in California cheap pug puppies for sale in nj Black Pug Puppies for sale pugs puppies for sale
Perfecthomepugs · 4 weeks and 4 days ago

What do you think?

Any thoughts on this command? Does it work on your machine? Can you do the same thing with only 14 characters?

You must be signed in to comment.

What's this?

commandlinefu.com is the place to record those command-line gems that you return to again and again. That way others can gain from your CLI wisdom and you from theirs too. All commands can be commented on, discussed and voted up or down.

Share Your Commands



Stay in the loop…

Follow the Tweets.

Every new command is wrapped in a tweet and posted to Twitter. Following the stream is a great way of staying abreast of the latest commands. For the more discerning, there are Twitter accounts for commands that get a minimum of 3 and 10 votes - that way only the great commands get tweeted.

» http://twitter.com/commandlinefu
» http://twitter.com/commandlinefu3
» http://twitter.com/commandlinefu10

Subscribe to the feeds.

Use your favourite RSS aggregator to stay in touch with the latest commands. There are feeds mirroring the 3 Twitter streams as well as for virtually every other subset (users, tags, functions,…):

Subscribe to the feed for: